The Burden of Philosophy: Evil and the Human Condition.

Kanterian, Edward

This article attempts to identify certain shortcomings in analytic philosophy as practised today. First, it identifies a disconnect between the darker aspects of the human condition and philosophers' inability to engage with them. Second, it locates this inability in a certain logic of detachment, explored by Peter Strawson. Third, it points out problems with Strawson's analysis, which it then tries to overcome, using Constantin Noica's account of the Platonising attitude philosophers are perennially tempted by – one of several ways in which humans try to overcome their fallen condition. This is contrasted with Thomas Nagel's valuable but still deficient discussion of the "cosmic question". This brings us, finally, to a reconsideration of an older tradition in philosophy, which focused more explicitly on human fallenness. Petrarch's Secretum meum is used as an example to show that while the failure of analytic philosophers has deep existential roots, it is not commendable. Philosophers must learn, again, to reflect on the darkness of the human soul – their own darkness.

ANALYTIC philosophy; CONDITIONALS (Logic); NAGEL, Thomas, 1937-; TRADITION (Philosophy); NOICA, Constantin; PHILOSOPHERS; THEORY of knowledge

Review of Ecumenical Studies, 2024, Vol 16, Issue 2, p291

2359-8093

Academic Journal

10.2478/ress-2024-0020