Moral Inequity in Organ Donation: An Examination of Age-Based Denial.

Diwan, Tayyab S.; Beaman, Lindsay R.

The decision to donate an organ is often the decision to save a loved one's life. Frequently recognized as an ultimate act of altruism, a person's choice to donate is embedded in their right to make decisions about their own body and well-being, free of coercion. To ensure donors are truly acting out of altruism, transplant professionals will not allow someone to donate if there are concerns of duress or inability to consent. Although the evaluation of potential donors is well-intentioned and necessary, stigma and assumptions about young adults can sometimes lead to their being denied the opportunity to donate based on age rather than evidence, thus infringing upon their bodily autonomy. This case examines the narrative of a young man trying to save his sister through kidney donation, and the ramifications of denying him the opportunity to do so, and how the transplant community can re-envision their role in protecting young adult donors.

ORGAN donation; DURESS (Law); WELL-being; ALTRUISM; DECISION making

Narrative Inquiry in Bioethics, 2024, Vol 14, Issue 3, p219

2157-1732

Academic Journal

10.1353/nib.2024.a947863