Background and Aims: In an effort to protect the development of the icewine production industry, this study aimed to find indicators to distinguish between authentic and non-authentic icewines. Methods and Results: Fully ripened berries were used to prepare three types of high-sugar grape juices: naturally frozen juice, refrigerator-frozen juice and concentrated juice. The content of phenolic acids and flavan-3-ols in the samples before and after fermentation was assayed. Significant differences were found in the individual level of most phenolic acids and flavan-3-ols except chlorogenic acid, sinapic acid and (−)-epicatechin among the three types of high-sugar juices. At the end of fermentation, there were significant differences in the wines, not attributable to the influence of yeasts. Conclusions: Vanillic acid, caffeic acid, (−)-epigallocatechin gallate, gentisic acid and syringic acid may be used as indicators of authentic icewine. Significance of the Study: This work provides a basis for distinguishing authentic icewine and controlling icewine quality.