We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
Crises and the history of science: a materialist rehabilitation.
- Authors
Giovannetti-Singh, Gianamar; Kent, Rory
- Abstract
Over the past four decades, historians of science have come to discard crisis as a guiding heuristic in 'big-picture' narratives of scientific change. In this article, we argue that it can be rehabilitated without reintroducing the conceptual drawbacks of earlier historiographies. We suggest that analysing material crises as distinct episodes of knowledge-in-the-making focuses attention on the mangling of science and social order. We distinguish material crises from Kuhnian intellectual crises; the analysis of material crises begins with the interactive dynamics of actor practices and performances, emergent within concrete social orders, rather than from technical breakdowns within isolable theoretical paradigms. Drawing on Reinhart Koselleck's account of crisis, we characterize such events as patterned shifts in the tempo of actor behaviours, which are brought about by real-time processes of realization. In addition to the familiar, contemporary cases of climate change and COVID-19, we sketch out how three historical crises transformed knowledge production in disparate ways: the Ming–Qing transition in late imperial China, crises of labour precarity in seventeenth-century Istanbul and the 1960 Sharpeville massacre in South Africa.
- Subjects
HISTORY of science; SOCIAL order; MATERIALS analysis; CLIMATE change; PRECARITY
- Publication
BJHS Themes, 2024, Vol 9, p39
- ISSN
2058-850X
- Publication type
Academic Journal
- DOI
10.1017/bjt.2024.4