We found a match
Your institution may have rights to this item. Sign in to continue.
- Title
Epistemic enhancement, pastism, and fossil anomalies in paleontology and ichnology.
- Authors
Mirza, Ali
- Abstract
This paper presents explication on how paleontologists reconstruct the past using fossils when good modern analogues are not available. I call these pastist methods to differentiate them from presentist methods in which such analogues are available. I do so by presenting two fossil cases: the problematica and graphoglyptids. I describe a forgotten heuristic, "analogue chaining," that involves jumping from fossil anomaly to fossil anomaly using one to make sense of the other in successive fashion, using the relations between fossils to guide reconstruction. I relate this to the philosophy of historical sciences in four ways. First, that methods like analogue chaining have a "linearity" meaning that there are limited ways in which to learn about specimens using analogues. Second, that they are intrinsically difficult to notice, i.e. invisible. Third, that linearity and invisibility put pressure on some accounts of optimism about historical sciences. Fourth, our cases provide novel forms of optimism based on epistemic enhancement: the phenomena that some questions regarding an event are better answered millions of years after its occurrence.
- Subjects
ICHNOLOGY; PALEONTOLOGY; FOSSILS; PHILOSOPHY of science; PALEONTOLOGISTS
- Publication
Biology & Philosophy, 2024, Vol 39, Issue 1, p1
- ISSN
0169-3867
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1007/s10539-023-09937-7