We found a match
Your institution may have rights to this item. Sign in to continue.
- Title
The Greek Origins of J. S. Mill's Happiness.
- Authors
Williams, Geraint
- Abstract
The larger topic which interests me is the general influence of the Greeks on Mill but here I shall concentrate on one aspect of this larger problem – can some of the difficulties which Mill is seen as getting into with his modified utilitarianism be better understood through an appreciation of the primacy of Greek views on happiness instead of the usual emphasis given to the Benthamite starting-point? The traditional objections to Mill's version of utility hardly need rehearsing: how can he admit a qualitative element into a scale which only objectively measures quantity? How can he include the higher nature of man in a scheme which only recognizes pleasures and pains? Whether these and other criticisms lead the commentator to condemn Mill's attempt or whether they act as a springboard to discover a plausible defence of Mill, there is today a consensus that Mill's trouble arises from tampering with Bentham as a result of later alien influences.
- Publication
Utilitas, 1996, Vol 8, Issue 1, p5
- ISSN
0953-8208
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1017/S0953820800004702