We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
A New and Controversial Approach to Dispute Resolution Under the U.S.-China Trade Agreement of 2020.
- Authors
Chow, Daniel C. K.
- Abstract
The United States has hailed the 2020 U.S-China Economic and Trade Agreement (USCTA) as a breakthrough in suspending the trade war between the United States and China. Under the USCTA, China committed to purchase $200 billion of U.S. goods and services and to implement significant new protections for U.S. intellectual property rights. However, the true significance of the USCTA lies in its role as part of a larger U.S. scheme to usurp the role of the World Trade Organization (WTO) in resolving international trade disputes. The USCTA is an ominous portent of the future of the WTO. The United States' scheme has three parts: first, cripple the WTO dispute settlement process so that WTO obligations become unenforceable; second, create a parallel dispute resolution mechanism in the USCTA to resolve USCTA and WTO disputes involving China that is under complete U.S. control; and third, induce China into violating its WTO obligations by granting the United States special privileges that can no longer be challenged by other WTO members due to the paralysis of the WTO dispute settlement system. Although proponents of the WTO have stated that the paralysis of the WTO dispute settlement system is a life or death dilemma, these proponents must realize that this is only the first step in a larger U.S. scheme against the WTO. The United States is continuing to erode the WTO through its use of trade agreements that create an alternative mechanism allowing the United States to enforce WTO obligations. Each country that signs such an agreement, like China, becomes an accomplice in the U.S.' plot to undermine the WTO. Each new agreement represents a fresh deterioration of the WTO system, which will only accelerate as the United States induces more nations to violate the WTO. The only way to save the WTO is for leading WTO nations to call for a full-scale multilateral negotiation on the WTO dispute settlement system that involves all WTO members. Proponents of the WTO must realize the urgency of the present crisis and act now before the decline of the WTO becomes irreversible.
- Subjects
WORLD Trade Organization; CHINA-United States relations; COMMERCIAL treaties; INTERNATIONAL trade disputes; DILEMMA; INTELLECTUAL property; DISPUTE resolution
- Publication
Harvard Negotiation Law Review, 2020, Vol 26, p31
- ISSN
1556-0546
- Publication type
Article