We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
Has Parliament Failed To Charge the "Tax on SIFT Partnerships"?
- Authors
Bloom, Brian; Wiener, Brandon
- Abstract
Part IX.1 of the Income Tax Act attempts to impose a tax on a "specified investment flow-through" (SIFT) partnership, in order that such a partnership and its investors be taxed in a manner similar to a public corporation and its shareholders. The purported charge to tax in part IX.1 provides that a SIFT partnership "is liable to a tax." The authors argue that the term "liable to," from a textual and contextual perspective, connotes a possibility or probability of incurring some thing, rather than an obligation to do that thing. Acknowledging that it would be astonishing for Parliament to have failed to charge part IX.1 tax, the authors argue that, owing to the very nature of a charge, as well as from normative and constitutional perspectives, a charge to tax must be drafted unambiguously and must clearly impose an obligation to pay the tax, and that it would be inappropriate for a court employing the so-called modern rule of interpretation to rely on purpose to save a charge. The authors, referring to recent jurisprudence of the Federal Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court of Canada, further argue, focusing squarely on principles of interpretation, that the "modern" rule itself may not even justify having resort to purpose in this case to override conflicting text. They conclude by noting that there is Supreme Court precedent for denying a tax claim on the basis that the legislation in question failed to impose a tax even though the intention to tax was clear, and that Parliament should not adopt retroactive changes to the law as a fix for deficient drafting.
- Subjects
CANADA; INCOME tax laws; TAXATION of business partnerships; CORPORATIONS; STOCKHOLDERS; CANADA. Supreme Court; CANADA. Federal Court of Appeals
- Publication
Canadian Tax Journal / Revue Fiscale Canadienne, 2011, Vol 59, Issue 1, p1
- ISSN
0008-5111
- Publication type
Article