We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
Aquinas as an Advocate of Abortion? The Appeal to ‘Delayed Animation’ in Contemporary Christian Ethical Debates on the Human Embryo.
- Authors
Jones, David Albert
- Abstract
It has become common, in both popular and scholarly discourse, to appeal to ‘delayed animation’ as an argument for abortion (DAAA). Augustine and Aquinas seemingly held that the rational soul was infused midway in pregnancy, and therefore did not regard early abortion as homicide. The authority of these thinkers is thus cited by some contemporary Christians as a reason to tolerate or, for proportionate reasons, to promote first-trimester abortion and embryo experimentation. The present essay is an exercise in aetiology. It examines the origins of DAAA. Distinctions are drawn between different forms of DAAA in historical context, premises, and conclusions. Some forms raise important anthropological questions, though these arguments are not indefeasible. The most popular forms of DAAA, which are typically framed as appeals to precedent, are the weakest, in that there is little precedent for DAAA before 1950. The argument is in fact a novelty in the tradition.
- Subjects
ABORTION &; Christianity; PREGNANCY; SOUL; HUMAN embryos; CHRISTIAN ethics
- Publication
Studies in Christian Ethics, 2013, Vol 26, Issue 1, p97
- ISSN
0953-9468
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1177/0953946812466495