We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
Organizational structure and human agency within the South African health system: a qualitative case study of health promotion.
- Authors
Rwafa-Ponela, Teurai; Goudge, Jane; Christofides, Nicola
- Abstract
Despite international recognition of health promotion (HP) as a cost-effective way to improve population health, it is not highly regarded nor is it sufficiently institutionalized in many health systems. This diminishes its ability to deliver on its public health promises. This paper examined the role of organizational structure and human agency within the South African health system (drawing on Giddens's structuration theory) in determining the extent of, and barriers to, the institutionalization of HP. We conducted a qualitative case study using a combination of in-depth interviews (n = 37), key informant interviews (n = 8) and one-day workshops (n = 5) with Department of Health (DoH) staff (HP and non-HP personnel) from national, provincial and district levels as well as external HP stakeholders. Within the South African health system, there are dedicated HP staffs, with no specified professional competencies or a coherent hierarchy of job titles. Allocated HP resources were frequently shifted to other programmes. This resulted in a disconnect between national and provincial levels, which impeded communication and opportunity to develop a shared vision and coherent programme. We found some examples of successful HP organization and implementation practices, such as the tobacco control legislation. Overall, HP staff had limited agency and were often unable to articulate the vision for HP. Uncertainty about the role of HP has led to powerlessness, and feelings of resentment have generated demotivation and moral distress. HP voices were seldom heard and were repressed by dominant curative-focused structures. If leaders of HP continue to be embedded in such an institution, there is little chance of driving an effective HP agenda. Therefore, there is a need to engage policy-makers to integrate HP into the health system fabric. Establishment of an independent HP foundation could be one mechanism to drive multi-sectoral collaboration, contribute to evidence-based HP research and further develop health in all policies through advocacy.
- Subjects
SOUTH Africa; AGENT (Philosophy); HEALTH promotion; ORGANIZATIONAL structure; QUALITATIVE research; JOB titles; HEALTH facilities; PUBLIC health; GOVERNMENT programs; JOB Descriptive Index; RESEARCH funding
- Publication
Health Policy & Planning, 2021, Vol 36, pi46
- ISSN
0268-1080
- Publication type
journal article
- DOI
10.1093/heapol/czab086