We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
Numbers do not add up! The pragmatic approach to the framing of medical treatments.
- Authors
Macchi, Laura; Zulato, Edoardo
- Abstract
The risky choice framing effect disclosed that presenting data in a loss scenario lead decision-makers towards risky choices. Conversely, a gain scenario prevents themfrom taking a risk. Framing effect robustness has been widely confirmed by psychological literature. However, the framing of medical treatments, based on McNeil et al. (1982) paradigm, raised both methodological doubts and contrasting evidence. Our research aimed to investigate the presence and the nature of the framing effect in the McNeil et al. (1982) paradigm. In particular, we thought that the obtained switch of preferences across frames was due to a misleading formulation of the data given in a negative cumulative frequency format. We conducted three studies: (1) we replicated McNeil et al.'s (1982) original study (N=150) with medicine (n=50), statistics (n=50) and lay (n=50) students; (2) we tested (N=180) our hypothesis by comparing a cumulative frequency format with an alternative version, namely a linear progression one; (3) we compared (N=430) the effect of different formats (cumulative frequency, linear progression and interval frequency) on choices. Our results showed that, while the framing effect is present when employing a cumulative frequency format, it disappears when using a linear progression one. Moreover, our results show that decision-makers better understand information when given in a linear progression and an interval frequency format. In the current paper, we argue that the way in which a problem is formulated plays a relevant role in the representation of the decisional task and the decision-making. Keywords: medical framing effect, reverse pattern of choice, understanding numerical information, pragmatic approach.
- Subjects
PRAGMATICS; THERAPEUTICS; PSYCHOLOGICAL literature; RISK-taking behavior; DECISION making
- Publication
Judgment & Decision Making, 2021, Vol 16, Issue 3, p596
- ISSN
1930-2975
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1017/s1930297500007750