We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
Jury Nullification and the Constituent Power of the People.
- Authors
Burns, Robert P.
- Abstract
Nullification constitutes a small, though important, part of what makes jury trial decision-making distinctive. The increasing bureaucratization of American criminal law means that what was thought to be the exercise of ordinary jury judgment has been transformed into nullification. Understandings that locate "We the People's" constituent power in sovereign will tend sharply to distinguish the extraordinary moment of constitution creation from the business of ordinary legality. Consequently, those understandings have difficulty imagining a nullifying jury's doing anything other than defying the will of the people. Hannah Arendt provides an understanding of the founding of the Constitution in the prerevolutionary political practices of the colonists that offers an understanding of jury nullification as more continuous with those practices and more continuous with ordinary jury decision-making.
- Subjects
ARENDT, Hannah, 1906-1975; CONSTITUENT power; JURY; AMERICAN law; CRIMINAL law; JURY trials
- Publication
Law, Culture & the Humanities, 2021, Vol 17, Issue 3, p394
- ISSN
1743-8721
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1177/1743872117716132