We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
A Signature‐Based Hydrologic Efficiency Metric for Model Calibration and Evaluation in Gauged and Ungauged Catchments.
- Authors
Kiraz, Melike; Coxon, Gemma; Wagener, Thorsten
- Abstract
Rainfall‐runoff models are commonly evaluated against statistical evaluation metrics. However, these metrics do not provide much insight into what is hydrologically wrong if a model fails to simulate observed streamflow well and they are also not applicable for ungauged catchments. Here, we propose a signature‐based hydrologic efficiency (SHE) metric by replacing the statistical components of current efficiency metrics with hydrologic signatures that can be regionalized for model evaluation in ungauged catchments. We test our new efficiency metric across 633 catchments from Great Britain. Strong correlations with Spearman rank and Pearson correlation values around 0.8 are found between our proposed metric and commonly used statistical evaluation metrics (NSE, KGE, and NP) demonstrating that the proposed SHE metric is related to existing metrics as much as these metrics are related to each other. For ungauged catchments, we regionalize the three signatures included in SHE and find that 78% of catchments have an absolute difference of SHE values between gauged and ungauged cases of less than 0.2. This difference varies depending on the quality of the regionalized bias and variance signature values. It means that the SHE metric is applicable for model evaluation in ungauged catchments if its signatures can be regionalized well. When applying the SHE metric in other domains with different hydrologic properties, modellers should carefully consider the components of the proposed metric with signatures best suited to their research domains and their regionalization potential. Key Points: We propose a signature‐based hydrologic efficiency metric that can be applied in both gauged and ungauged catchmentsWe use it to assess model performances in over 600 catchments in Great Britain and compare it to established efficiency metricsModellers should replace the components of the proposed metric with signatures best suited to the hydrology of their study domains
- Subjects
UNITED Kingdom; GAGING; PEARSON correlation (Statistics); RANK correlation (Statistics); CALIBRATION; WATERSHEDS; STREAMFLOW
- Publication
Water Resources Research, 2023, Vol 59, Issue 11, p1
- ISSN
0043-1397
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1029/2023WR035321