We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
Evidence-Based Policymaking during the COVID-19 Crisis: Regulatory Impact Assessments and the Polish COVID-19 Restrictions.
- Authors
Jonski, Kamil; Rogowski, Wojciech
- Abstract
The COVID-19 pandemic transformed our understanding of the state's role during a public health crisis and introduced an array of unprecedented policy tools: ever-stricter travel restrictions, lockdowns and closures of whole branches of the economy. Evidence-based policymaking seems to be the gold standard of such high-stakes policy interventions. This article presents an empirical investigation into the regulatory impact assessments accompanying sixty-four executive acts (regulations) introducing antipandemic restrictions in Poland over the first year of the pandemic. To this end, the study utilises the so-called scorecard methodology, which is popular in regulatory impact assessment research. This methodology highlights the shallowness of these documents and the accompanying processes, with an absence not only of a sound evidence base behind specific anti-pandemic measures or estimates of their economic impacts, but even of the comparative data on restrictions introduced in other European Union/Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries. Overall, the collected data support the hypothesis that the ad hoc pandemic management process crowded out the law-making process through tools such as regulatory impact assessments and consultations. In other words, the genuine decision-making occurred elsewhere (with the exact process being largely invisible to public opinion and scholars) and drafting legal texts simply codified these decisions, with the law-making process becoming mere window-dressing.
- Subjects
POLAND; REGULATORY impact analysis; COVID-19 pandemic; EUROPEAN Union; ORGANISATION for Economic Co-operation &; Development; POLICY sciences; COVID-19; TRAVEL restrictions
- Publication
European Journal of Risk Regulation, 2023, Vol 14, Issue 1, p65
- ISSN
1867-299X
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1017/err.2022.18