We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
Domesticating Hasidism: Neo-Hasidism, Modernity, and the Postmodern Turn.
- Authors
Magid, Shaul
- Abstract
This essay critically engages various contemporary readings of Hasidism. It examines what I call a "domesticating" orientation in Hasidic research, a quasi-apologetic move to read the academic study of Hasidism back into a normative Orthodox framework. I argue this is, in part, a resistance to what I call a "neo-Hasidic" orientation of a previous generation, scholars who sought to use Hasidism as the basis for their modern, existentialist, and renewal projects. This essay argues that while the domesticating critique has some merit, it overestimates its own objectivity and misses crucial aspects of the neo-Hasidic interpretation it seeks to undermine. I then use the work of Rav Shagar and what I am calling his "postmodern" reading of Hasidism as a critique of the domesticating trend that adopts, while also criticizing, the neo-Hasidic interpretation. In sum I argue that Rav Shagar presents a template that cuts through and moves beyond the modernizing and normative trajectories to open vistas for new understandings of Hasidism for our time.
- Subjects
HASIDISM; MODERNITY; JEWISH sects; EXISTENTIALISM; POSTMODERNISM (Philosophy); MODERNISM (Literary period); POSTMODERNISM (Literary period)
- Publication
Jewish Quarterly Review, 2022, Vol 112, Issue 4, p1
- ISSN
0021-6682
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1353/jqr.2022.0035