We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
Zero-Tolerance Policies: Do They Inhibit or Stimulate Illicit Drug Consumption.
- Authors
Caulkins, Jonathan P.
- Abstract
Some have suggested fighting the drug problem with so-called "zero-tolerance" policies that impose stiff sanctions for possession of even trace amounts of illicit drugs. Such policies can swamp the criminal justice system and violate the principle that the punishment should fit the crime, but these objections have often been suppressed by an overriding desire to minimize consumption. This paper argues to the contrary that under plausible conditions zero-tolerance policies may actually encourage controlled users to consume more, not less, than they would if the punishment increased in proportion to the quantity possessed at the time of arrest. This result holds even if for every quantity the punishment under the proportional policy is less than or equal to that under the zero-tolerance policy. The argument relies on a mathematical model that describes how a typical controlled user's purchasing habits are affected by the punishment anticipated as a function of the quantity possessed. A variety of possible punishment policies are evaluated. The consumption minimizing policy for a given individual user is obtained, as well as the consumption minimizing policy that belongs to a restricted class of policies that are more likely to be politically feasible.
- Subjects
DRUG control; ZERO-tolerance school policies; CRIME prevention; DRUGS of abuse; CRIMINAL justice system; DRUG abuse prevention; MATHEMATICAL models; PUNISHMENT in crime deterrence; CONTROLLED substances
- Publication
Management Science, 1993, Vol 39, Issue 4, p458
- ISSN
0025-1909
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1287/mnsc.39.4.458