We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
Response to Coomes & Allen (2009) 'Testing the metabolic scaling theory of tree growth'.
- Authors
Stark, Scott C.; Bentley, Lisa Patrick; Enquist, Brian J.
- Abstract
propose a new statistical method to test the Metabolic Scaling Theory prediction for tree growth rate size scaling (scaling constant α = 1/3) presented in . This method finds values of the scaling constant that yield standardized major axis (SMA) slopes of one in a comparison of allometrically transformed diameter census data. This SMA 'slope-of-one' method produces results that contrast with those generated by maximum-likelihood estimation (MLE; ; ). We hypothesize that the SMA slope-of-one method is inappropriate for this application because it assumes, unrealistically, that there is no biological or error variance in tree growth size scaling. To test our hypothesis, we simulate 'allometric' tree growth with biological and error variance in parameters and measurements. We find that the SMA slope-of-one method is sensitive to the amount of biological and error variance and consistently returns biassed parameter estimates, while the MLE method displays relatively little bias, particularly at larger sample sizes. Synthesis. The conclusions of should be reconsidered in the light of our findings. Investigations of tree growth rate size scaling must consider the influence of biological and error variance in model-fitting procedures to ultimately unravel the effects of tree architecture and ecological factors on patterns of size-dependent growth.
- Subjects
TREE growth; ALLOMETRY in plants; PLANT growth; PLANT ecology; STATISTICS
- Publication
Journal of Ecology, 2011, Vol 99, Issue 3, p741
- ISSN
0022-0477
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1111/j.1365-2745.2010.01719.x