We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
You Can't Always Get (or Give) What You Want: Preferences and Their Limits.
- Authors
Berlinger, Nancy
- Abstract
Abstract: People who lack decision‐making capacity may be able to communicate preferences, which can and should inform surrogate decision‐making on their behalf. It is unclear whether making a further distinction about “capacity for preferences,” as Jason Wasserman and Mark Navin propose in this issue of the Hastings Center Report , would improve the process of surrogate decision‐making. Anyone who is regularly involved in surrogate decision‐making or who has worked to articulate decision‐making standards and processes can think of cases in which a patient's voice was ignored or his or her preferences and ability to communicate them overlooked. However, we can also think of cases in which it was unclear whether information provided by a patient, recently or in the past, should have been characterized as a preference relevant to a medical decision that the patient lacked the capacity to make. We should also recognize that clear preferences of a patient who lacks decision‐making capacity may conflict with the limits of another person or of a family's resources such that these preferences cannot guide a surrogate's decision. This patient will not get what he wants. A situation in which preferences are known and make sense but cannot be applied in a feasible way demonstrates the limits of the medical decision‐making framework concerning care that is not covered by medical insurance.
- Subjects
MYOCARDIAL infarction risk factors; BLOOD pressure; CAREGIVERS; COGNITION disorders; CORONARY artery bypass; DIZZINESS; ACCIDENTAL falls; HOSPICE care; LEWY body dementia; MEDICARE; MYOCARDIAL infarction; NURSING care facilities; PROXY; STAFFS (Sticks, canes, etc.); DECISION making in clinical medicine; PARKINSONIAN disorders; PATIENT decision making
- Publication
Hastings Center Report, 2018, Vol 48, Issue 3, p40
- ISSN
0093-0334
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1002/hast.854