We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
Chinese Legal Thought on the Global and the Domestic Stage: A Rhetorical Study.
- Authors
Seppänen, Samuli
- Abstract
Chinese Communist Party ideologues and a number of prominent legal scholars have become outspoken about the global significance of Chinese legal thought. The question is, however, whether the ambitious statements about the global importance of Chinese legal thought are supported by legal theoretical arguments, which could be influential abroad. This article examines the interaction between the domestic and global stages of Chinese legal speech through the tools of rhetorical theory. Arguments about the nature and global significance of Chinese law are made for different purposes and for different audiences. The most ambitious statements about the global significance of Chinese legal thought are produced within a 'ceremonial' genre of speech. Domestic Chinese ceremonial speech is meaningful in the Chinese context, but it translates poorly to globally influential ideological speech. Foreign audiences will find more persuasive arguments about the significance of Chinese legal thought in Chinese deliberative speech, such as parts of Chinese legal scholarship. While arguments made in the deliberative genre are more persuasive than ceremonial speech, specific argumentative moves within this genre are not always helpful for the international advocacy of Chinese legal thought. Moreover, arguments in the deliberative genre are not consistently reflected in Chinese judicial decisions. These observations highlight the role of language and persuasion in the globalisation of law.
- Subjects
CHINESE Communist Party; CHINESE language; LEGAL judgments; RHETORICAL theory; PERSUASION (Rhetoric); COMMUNIST parties
- Publication
Asian Journal of Comparative Law, 2023, Vol 18, Issue 2, p158
- ISSN
1932-0205
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1017/asjcl.2023.5