We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
The Constitution of Parenthood.
- Authors
NeJaime, Douglas
- Abstract
This Article challenges the conventional assumption that the Constitution protects only biological parent-child relationships and makes an affirmative case for constitutional protection for nonbiological parents. Family law in a growing number of states legally recognizes nonbiological parents in a range of families--including nonmarital families, families headed by same-sex couples, and families formed through assisted reproduction. But in some states, nonbiological parents who have not adopted are treated as legal strangers to their children. When these parents turn to the Constitution to assert a liberty interest in their parent-child relationship, they find no relief. Courts conclude that only biological parents possess a right to parental recognition protected by the Due Process Clause. This biological understanding of constitutional parenthood often rests on a reading of Supreme Court precedents from the 1970s and 1980s involving the rights of unmarried fathers and the status of foster parents. This Article revisits those precedents--both to show that they present a more complicated approach to parenthood than conventionally assumed and to make clear the ways in which they are in tension with more recent constitutional commitments. Rather than elaborate a biological approach to parenthood, the Court's decisions on unmarried fathers and foster parents view parenthood as a social practice. Even as these precedents provide useful insights about parenthood's social dimensions, they are outdated. Decided decades ago, these decisions condone forms of inequality that now appear constitutionally suspect. Since they were decided, legal understandings of the family have shifted significantly. The Court itself has contributed to the changing legal landscape through its decisions on the constitutional rights of same-sex couples--who ordinarily include nonbiological parents.
- Subjects
UNITED States; PARENTHOOD; DOMESTIC relations; PARENT-child relationships; CIVIL rights; DUE process of law; NONBIOLOGICAL fathers; LEGAL status of birthparents; NONBIOLOGICAL mothers
- Publication
Stanford Law Review, 2020, Vol 72, Issue 2, p261
- ISSN
0038-9765
- Publication type
Article