We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
First Amendment Constraints on Proposition 65.
- Authors
Manheim, Jacob
- Abstract
The Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, better known as Proposition 65, requires businesses to warn individuals before exposing them to chemicals that are "known to the State of California" to cause cancer or reproductive harm. The law endured for more than three decades without any successful free speech challenges to its compelled warnings. However, the legal landscape fundamentally changed in 2018 when the Supreme Court seemingly expanded First Amendment protections for professional speech in National Institute of Family and Life Advocates v. Becerra. Justice Thomas's majority opinion made clear that laws compelling commercial speech are subject to heightened scrutiny unless the compelled speech is purely factual, noncontroversial, and not unduly burdensome. Business groups, eternally opposed to placing cancer warnings on their products, seized upon the new legal framework and successfully challenged the warning requirements for two of Proposition 65's most controversial listed chemicals--acrylamide and glyphosate. This Note examines the fate of Proposition 65 in the aftermath of California Chamber of Commerce v. Council for Education & Research on Toxics, a 2022 Ninth Circuit case that affirmed a preliminary injunction against enforcement of the acrylamide cancer warning. While future First Amendment challenges may lead to injunctions against some existing warnings and restrict Proposition 65's ability to respond to chemicals of emerging concern, this Note concludes that the voter-enacted law will continue to play a significant role in safeguarding public health.
- Subjects
UNITED States. Constitution. 1st Amendment; HAZARDOUS substance exposure; SAFE Drinking Water Act (U.S.); FREEDOM of speech; COMMERCIAL speech; ACRYLAMIDE; GLYPHOSATE; PUBLIC health
- Publication
Ecology Law Quarterly, 2023, Vol 50, Issue 2, p481
- ISSN
0046-1121
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.15779/Z38CJ87M9P