We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
The fine-grained metaphysics of artifactual and biological functional kinds.
- Authors
Carrara, Massimiliano; Vermaas, Pieter E.
- Abstract
In this paper we consider the emerging position in metaphysics that artifact functions characterize real kinds of artifacts. We analyze how it can circumvent an objection by David Wiggins ( Sameness and substance renewed, 2001, 87) and then argue that this position, in comparison to expert judgments, amounts to an interesting fine-grained metaphysics: taking artifact functions as (part of the) essences of artifacts leads to distinctions between principles of activity of artifacts that experts in technology have not yet made. We show, moreover, that our argument holds not only in the artifactual realm but also in biology: taking biological functions as (part of the) essences of organs leads to distinctions between principles of activity of organs that biological experts have not yet made. We run our argument on the basis of analyses of artifact and biological functions as developed in philosophy of technology and of biology, thus importing results obtained outside of metaphysics into the debate on ontological realism. In return, our argument shows that a position in metaphysics provides experts reason for trying to detect differences between principles of activities of artifacts and organs that have not been detected so far.
- Subjects
METAPHYSICS; PHILOSOPHICAL anthropology; WIGGINS, David; BIOLOGY; PHILOSOPHY of mind
- Publication
Synthese, 2009, Vol 169, Issue 1, p125
- ISSN
0039-7857
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1007/s11229-008-9339-1