We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
The space of possibilities of dispositional essentialism.
- Authors
Lanao, Xavi
- Abstract
How we define the space of possibilities of dispositional essentialism (DE)—that is, the set of possible worlds that are genuinely possible from the point of view of DE—has important consequences for central modal debates such as how to understand the concept of essence or the relation between DE and the necessity of laws of nature. In order to define DE’s space of possibilities we need to explore DE’s consequences regarding both necessity and possibility. Unfortunately, the notion of possibility has not received much attention within the DE literature. In this paper, I attempt to fill this gap. I argue that the standard way of understanding possibility found in the literature—a proposition is possible iff it expresses the manifestation of some actual disposition—needlessly restricts the space of possibilities by not accepting global and absolute possibilities, including some alien properties, as genuinely possible. I propose instead to accept a more permissive understanding of possibility: a proposition is possible iff it does not contradict any of the necessities that follow from the core commitments of DE. This allows dispositionalists to expand their modal space and to account for modal intuitions that may otherwise undermine the tenability of DE.
- Subjects
POSSIBILITY; PHILOSOPHY; PROBABILITY theory; DISPOSITION (Philosophy); ESSENTIALISM (Philosophy); SUBSTANCE (Philosophy); NATURAL law
- Publication
Philosophical Studies, 2018, Vol 175, Issue 11, p2813
- ISSN
0031-8116
- Publication type
Article
- DOI
10.1007/s11098-017-0983-5