We found a match
Your institution may have access to this item. Find your institution then sign in to continue.
- Title
Utility of Follow-Up MRI for Sciatica.
- Authors
Rubin, Michael
- Abstract
Afflicting 80% of americans at some point in their lives, and 50% in any given year, low back pain is the second leading cause for physician visits in this country, the third leading cause for surgical procedures, the fifth leading cause for hospitalizations, and accounts for more than $24 billion a year in direct medical costs. Best practices that might positively impact these statistics would be welcome, and the present study, examining the value of obtaining follow-up magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) at 1 year in patients with persistent sciatica and known to have lumbar-disc herniation, is a first step in this direction. Patients in this study had participated in a multicenter, randomized trial comparing conservative management to surgery for lumbar disc herniation with sciatica, having been eligible if they experienced 6-12 weeks of sciatica and demonstrated disc herniation on MRI, with pain in a dermatomal distribution associated with neurologic findings corresponding to the nerve root affected on imaging. MRI was performed at baseline and repeated at 1 year. Complete or near complete resolution of patient-reported symptoms at 1 year, using the 7-point Likert self-rating scale of global perceived recovery, was defined as a favorable outcome, and was measured at baseline and at 2, 4, 8, 12, 26, 38, and 52 weeks. Patients were blinded to the results of their MRI findings and prior assessments. Statistical analysis included student's t-test and logistic regression models, and model-based multiple imputation was used to account for missing data. Among 599 patients screened for the trial, 283 were randomized, and after 1 year, 267 were available for a second MRI (94.3%). Of these 267 patients, 131 had been randomized to surgery, of which 15 recovered before surgery, and 136 were randomized to receive conservative care, of which 54 underwent surgery within the first year. At 1 year, a favorable outcome was achieved in 84%, based on the 7-point Likert scale. In the as-treated analysis, a herniated disc was present at 1 year in 21% of patients treated surgically and 60% of those treated conservatively. In the intention-to-treat analysis, a herniated disc was present in 22% of the former and 47% of the latter. Among those with a favorable outcome, 35% demonstrated disc herniation on MRI at 1 year, compared to 33% among those with an unfavorable outcome, with nerve root compression visible on imaging in 24% and 26%, respectively. Of 170 patients who had surgery, 88% (150) demonstrated a visible scar on MRI, of which 86% reported a favorable outcome, compared to 75% with no scar (P = 0.19). Among those with a definite, probable, or possible disc herniation, favorable outcome was reported in 85% at 1 year, compared to 83% among those with no disc herniation. Follow-up MRI at 1 year did not distinguish between those who improved and those who did not, and MRI is not warranted in this clinical setting as a routine follow-up examination.
- Subjects
SCIATICA treatment; DIAGNOSTIC imaging; PATIENT aftercare; MAGNETIC resonance imaging; MEDICAL care; EVALUATION of medical care; PATIENTS; PRIMARY health care; SCIATICA; DIAGNOSIS
- Publication
Neurology Alert, 2013, Vol 31, Issue 9, p67
- ISSN
0741-4234
- Publication type
Article